The project is divided into several work packages, each dealing with different aspects of research, implementation and dissemination. These work packages ensure a systematic approach to analyzing the effectiveness of the new legal framework for cross-border access to electronic evidence in criminal matters.
The first work package focuses on the overall coordination and management of the project. This includes administrative tasks, financial management and ensuring compliance with reporting obligations. In addition, this work package includes cooperation with funding bodies and other relevant stakeholders.
The second work package includes a comprehensive review of the two sets of regulations (e-evidence regulation and directive) and - where available - their national implementing legislation to enable an assessment of the legal and theoretical basis. The responsible team will analyze how these instruments impact current MLA procedures, focusing on potential gaps and challenges in their implementation. These steps are also linked to the other work packages and are therefore crucial for the success of the project.
Work package 3 focuses on conducting empirical research to assess how different stakeholders view the new EU rules, building on the research conducted in the second work package. To this end, interviews will be conducted with representatives of the judiciary (judges and prosecutors), various service providers and NGOs in all three participating EU Member States. The interviews will also be supplemented by focus group discussions in which experts from the above-mentioned areas will exchange views on the new regulations. The results should provide insights into the practical challenges of cross-border data access and help to evaluate the effectiveness of the new MLA mechanisms.
Work package 4 shifts the research focus to the compatibility of the new legal MLA framework with existing data protection laws. The aim is to assess whether these instruments are in line with fundamental rights standards, in particular with regard to data protection provisions (such as the GDPR) and rule of law procedural safeguards.
The final work package of the project focuses on translating the research findings into practical guidelines and concrete policy recommendations. The responsible project team will work with policy makers, legal experts and international organizations to present its findings. In addition, the results will be disseminated through various channels, including academic publications, to ensure that the research findings reach both an academic audience and practitioners.
The team at the University of Cologne (Chair of Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure and Criminal Policy) has extensive experience in empirical legal research, particularly in relation to interviews with members of the judiciary and law enforcement agencies. This expertise is crucial for the management of work packages 1 and 3 as well as for the support of work packages 2 and 5.
The project team of the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki will focus on work package 2. Its task is to ensure a comprehensive analysis of the legal and procedural aspects of the new mutual legal assistance instruments and to assess their impact in different legal systems. The tasks will focus in particular on normative research on the foundations of criminal procedure that are related to and potentially affected by the adaptations of traditional mutual legal assistance mechanisms.
A decisive role in work package 4 is played by the team of the Chair of Digitalization Law at the University of Cologne, which, among other things, examines the compatibility of new mutual legal assistance mechanisms with the GDPR and the Law Enforcement Directive[1] will analyze. Its research will help to assess data protection risks and make recommendations to ensure legal certainty in data transfers.
The University of Vienna project team will focus on the impact on fundamental rights to be taken into account when considering the new legal framework for international mutual legal assistance. In particular, this team will work closely with the teams of work packages 2 and 4 to complement their findings with a fundamental rights perspective. In addition, this team will participate in work package 3 in order to contribute the Austrian perspective.
[1] Directive (EU) 2016/680 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data by competent authorities for the purposes of the prevention, investigation, detection or prosecution of criminal offenses.